The outcome of the Panini and Fanatics lawsuit, or actually lawsuits, could have serious implications for sports card hobbyists and investors alike going forward. A couple of weeks ago we posted an article about Fanatics’ over the top entry into the market and even then our keen and astute observation was that “there could be an anti-trust lawsuit here if anyone happens to be looking for one”, but we didn’t dare say it out loud. Now we doubt that Panini was actually looking for this fight, but through a recent acquisition, Fanatics literally brought the fight to Panini’s doorstep and the outcome of the Panini and Fanatics lawsuit may just touch us all.
The Acquisition behind the Panini and Fanatics Lawsuit
If you think we’re talking about the acquisition of Topps by Fanatics in 2021, then you’re half right. That purchase, coming closely on the heels of Fanatics negotiating to take major sports league licensing deals away from industry leaders Topps and Panini, was a one two punch from Fanatics to Topps. At the time of the licensing negotiations Topps was also involved in acquistion talks. Once Topps lost their MLB license, their valuation plummeted by more than 60% and that deal died. Fanatics was able to gobble them up for about one third of their previous valuation.
Red flags were already going up at Panini, however it was Fanatics’ next move that got the lawyers involved. Last year Fanatics quietly made two large investments giving them controlling interest in the Dallas area based printer GC Packaging which is literally across town from the Panini America headquarters.
**NOTE: Okay we know that Panini is in Irving and GC Packaging is in Mesquite and Allen and that Dallas is a huge city, but on the scale of Texas it’s the same as across town for the rest of us!**
What’s the Big Deal?
It’s not proximity of the investment that has Panini up in arms, it’s the fact that Panini is GC Packaging’s largest customer with some estimates saying GC Packaging is responsible for up to 90% of Panini’s printing needs, and around 40% of Topps (now Fanatics) requirements. This means that in addition1 to controlling the licensing for the most popular sports leagues in this country, Fanatics now controls Panini’s printing operations. In the Panini and Fanatics lawsuit Panini alleges that Fanatics is manipulating this relationship to hurt Panini and now has access to certain trade secrets that make Panini cards unique and that all of this gives Fanatics an unfair advantage in the market.
Is This a Monopoly?
In our opinion Panini has a strong argument. One company controlling the licensing and having a controlling interest in the manufacturing would definitely seem to have an unfair advantage over the competition, but a counter suit to the Panini and Fanatics lawsuit filed by Fanatics disagrees. Fanatics claims in its lawsuit against Panini that Panini did not negotiate in good faith and lost their NBA license to a better deal for the league, and that the GC Packaging investment was done to strengthen the company which they contend was having issues with order fulfillment and quality control.
Regardless of which side of the Panini and Fanatics lawsuit you land on, two things are undeniable. We are witnessing a world class bare knuckle brawl being fought with briefcases by rich guys in Brooks Brothers suits.
What Does The Panini and Fanatics Lawsuit Mean to the Average Collector?
The ongoing legal disputes between Fanatics and Panini, along with other changes in the sports trading card market, have left many collectors and investors uncertain about the future. While it’s difficult to predict the outcome of the Panini and Fanatics lawsuit, it’s clear that the industry is in a period of transition. It remains to be seen who the major players will be in the years to come, and what kind of legal battles will arise as a result. For the time being, it’s important for those involved in the market to stay informed and keep an eye on developments as they unfold.
So, what does this mean for collectors and investors? If Panini’s allegations are true, it could mean that Fanatics has a stranglehold on the market and ultimately harms consumers. When any single company holds a monopoly on a product, they have the ability to dictate prices and limit consumer choice. This could have long-term negative effects on the industry and make it harder for collectors and investors to access the products they want.
Conclusion
It’s worth noting here that the Panini and Fanatics lawsuit is ongoing, and Fanatics has not been found guilty of any wrongdoing. It’s entirely possible that the allegations will be proven to be without merit, and Fanatics will continue to operate as normal. But even if they are found to have violated antitrust laws, it’s unclear what the specific outcome will be. They could be forced to divest certain assets or undergo other changes, or they could simply face a fine.
As the case continues, it’s important to monitor developments and the strategies used by both companies. The Panini vs. Fanatics lawsuit highlights just how big the sports trading card industry has become—no longer just a hobby, but serious business. For hobby news, updates, and cards, visit Boiling Springs Sports Cards

0 Comments